The Apocalypto Scenes Mel Gibson DID Borrow (Probably)January 5th, 2007 in Directors, Movies |
With the recent news that Mel Gibson is being sued for (allegedly) stealing scenes for Apocalypto from a Mexican director, here’s a quick reminder of some other scenes in Apocalypto that ring a few bells.
For the record - and because Mel Gibson can probably afford some very expensive lawyers - this isn’t meant to imply that Gibson “stole” any of these scenes or that he should be sued or anything quite as silly. Merely that several scenes in Apocalypto are very similar to scenes in the following movies…
Return Of The Jedi: The early, peaceful scenes in Jaguar Paw’s Mayan village could easily be replaced with the Ewok village scenes from Jedi, so sweet and innocent are they.
The Fugitive: When Jaguar Paw is hunted to the edge of a waterfall, it looks like he’s done for. Luckily he saw The Fugitive and remembered how Harrison Ford escaped a similar situation.
Midnight Cowboy: As the aggressive Mayan leader marches his fresh captives back to the city, some careless workers fell a tree in his path, nearly crushing him. “I’m walking here!” he yells at them, just like Dustin Hoffman in Midnight Cowboy. Presumably he’d have banged on the hood of a yellow taxi cab too, had one been available.
Braveheart: OK, so it’s his film to begin with. But Mel still rehashes the Braveheart scene where the English invaders slit Mel’s missus throat in front of him, only this time it’s Jaguar Paw’s dad.
Predator: Jaguar Paw must have seen the Arnie flick too. Which is lucky because he remembers to cover himself in mud while being hunted in the jungle, just like the Governor of California did.
Planet Of The Apes: The good one not the Mark Wahlberg one. Without ruining the ending of either film (and by either film I mean the original Planet Of The Apes and Apocalypto, I couldn’t tell you what happens at the end of Tim Burton’s Planet Of The Apes if I wanted to) they both end when the central character discovers something shocking on a beach, something that means they’re going to have to rethink a few things.
Popularity: 1% [?]
Stumble it! / Bookmark:



January 6th, 2007 at 11:49 am
Every director borrows ideas from other filmmakers. Clint Eastwood’s opening scene in Flags of our Fathers is borrowed from Spielberg’s Saving Private Ryan.
Every battle scene now imitates Gibson’s Braveheart. All of Scorcese’ films borrow from Coppola’s The Godfather and Ed Zwick borrows from all of them.
This is a weak article with weak ideas with Gibson’s name attached because he’s been in the limelight recently.
The writer of this article is obviously covering her/his rear end with the word (probably)because they don’t want to be sued.
Find another subject and do your homework properly.
January 6th, 2007 at 11:31 pm
The opening scene in Flags of Our Fathers is borrowed from Saving Private Ryan because Flags was initially a Steven Spielberg project. He was heavily involved as a producer even though Eastwood directed it.
It’s still true that every director borrows ideas from other filmmakers. The big difference is that Gibson borrows heavily from all over the place without attribution, and without rally altering or improving what he’s borrows.
So in light of his being sued by Juan Catlett, it’s worthwhile pointing out just what a little magpie he is.
January 7th, 2007 at 8:50 pm
I think Daryl’s article is spot on. You see, the problem with Apocalypto proposes to be something different, something extraordinary. But after seeing it today, I felt nothing, not hatred, not love. For it is merely a Hollywood chase movie, full of the cliched scenes (e.g. waterfall jumping) with typical family values disguised as an art-house film. and that’s just because it’s subtitled. There’s no new ground, it just hides a tired old tale in ancient Mayan culture.
I bestow upon this film a great big yawn, and was glad I snuck into the cinema and didn’t pay for it.
January 10th, 2007 at 10:11 pm
I think this was a really good movie.Action all the way,the acting in this film was outstanding .But i can safely say no actors will win any awards though. but well done MELL GIBSON
January 13th, 2007 at 4:25 am
Check out Cornel Wilde’s great 60s action/explotation flick The Naked Prey.
You’ll be feeling some de-javu
February 7th, 2007 at 12:11 pm
So you’re dying in quick sand, and are struggling to get out safely. How is this possibly stealing the idea from Predator?
February 7th, 2007 at 3:30 pm
also ther’s that scene thst loocks just like the one in the brasilian movie ”cidade de deus”, when the Jaguar’s Paw while running from the mayan’s in forest, climb’s up on a tree, and when hes blood, falls down.
I don’t know any of you people seen that movie but it’s wery simular to it.
February 7th, 2007 at 3:35 pm
i forgot to mention, i realy, realy liked the ovie and all.