Lights, Camera, Begorrah! The Best and Worst of Irish CinemaMarch 14th, 2007 in Actors, Movies |
With St. Patrick’s Day fast approaching (and our livers recoiling in proportion), what better time to celebrate the glories of the tiny nation that is Ireland? Aside from our notorious drunken behaviour, this country has also managed to produce some distinguished literary figures (James Joyce, Samuel Beckett, Oscar Wilde, to name a few). Even in music U2 (pictured left) are a house hold name. In cinema Pierce Brosnan and Liam Neeson have graced the acting world. But what of Ireland as a filmmaking nation?
There are more film courses in this country than necessary. Throw a stone in Dublin and you’re likely to strike an aspiring director. But most of the low-budget films in Ireland aren’t even successful in the domestic box office, often due to being Irish imitations of established hits (e.g. the “Irish Shallow Graveâ€), and thus being of no international interest. The Wind that Shakes the Barley has been receiving awards and gets a limited release in the US this weekend, appropriately, but is nevertheless flawed. However, there have been a few breakout hits, either commercially or artistically, that deserve to be added to the canon of Irish achievements.
These films are those that received substantial funding from Ireland, and were either produced by or explicitly about the emerald isle. Hence, the omission of The Crying Game, despite its brilliance.
This recent addition to Irish cinema is a witty yet sombre story of a day in the lives of two Dublin junkies. They trudge through the city, their cravings getting them into disastrous situations. They stumble across the wake of a friend whose death was somehow related to them. Newcomer Lenny Abrahamson adopts the tragi-comedy and resonant silences that made Beckett’s plays so kinetic with meaning, while occasionally employing sensual visuals, making it a 21st century Irish tale.
This endearing comedy revived a flagging national film industry in the early 90s. Backed by an internationally recognised director (Alan Parker, director of Midnight Express, and…er… Fame) and based on the popular novel of profane writer Roddy Doyle, it concerned a young man living in the poor area of Northern Dublin, who sets up a soul band. it’s the first film to truly capture the hilarity and madness that is being a Dub, and has far more heart than the sterile Dreamgirls. Plus every Irish household is obliged by law to own a copy of The Commitments soundtrack.
No, Buster Keaton was not Irish. Rather, the Irish media has a habit of labelling its gangsters with titles. This film portrays the life of Martin “The General†Cahill, a notorious Dublin criminal, known for his wit as much as his crimes. He played to the media, and learned as much about legal loopholes as the average lawyer. And in his spare time he stole gold, diamonds, and priceless paintings. Played by the wonderful Brendan Gleeson (Gangs of New York, AI, Braveheart), Cahill is shown to be both a genius and a brutal thug. John Boorman’s film is one of the most in-depth portrayals of the ambiguous existence of a criminal since Goodfellas.
This is the father of Irish cinema, the first film to put the native industry on the international map. It was nominated for several of the main Oscars in 1990. Director Jim Sheridan made his feature film debut by adapting the memoirs of cerebral palsy victim and artist Christy Brown. Its greatness is due to being distinctly Irish, while managing to portray a disabled person without resorting to the sentimental conventions of TV movies. Christy Brown was as frustrated and as tough as Dublin at the time, and Daniel Day Lewis was astoundingly convincing in his Oscar-winning lead role (Day Lewis apparently never broke character during the filming period). Brenda Fricker also claimed a golden statuette as Best Supporting Actress for her role as Christy’s sympathetic mother.
By the mid 90s, director Neil Jordan had already established himself. Through the success of The Crying Game, he went on to make the sexually ambiguous Interview with the Vampire, and the flawed Irish epic Michael Collins. Jordan is a man who cannot escape Ireland’s clutches, and returned to indigenous tales to adapt a novel by bog-gothic writer Patrick McCabe. The Butcher Boy is one of the most faithful adaptations I’ve ever seen. It follows Francie Brady, a disturbed child from a dysfunctional 60’s village household, who runs by the rules of his own demented delusions. When his laws clash with those of repressed and repressive Ireland, we get a story that is funny and simultaneously grotesque, and utterly distinct.
I should also give a shout out to Pavee Lackeen for dealing with the Irish itinerant community in a touching manner, and Paul Greengrass’s Bloody Sunday for being the best film about the “Troubles†of Northern Ireland.
Of course, we’ve made plenty of stinkers too. too many for my liking. Last year saw John Boorman’s The Tiger’s Tail, a scathing assault on the affluence of modern Ireland, and a ham-fisted raving of an old man out of synch with modern life. Bloom was an attempted adaptation of Joyce’s Ulysses, and felt more like a stage performance, so lacking it was in visual style. And then there was Ordinary Decent Criminal, pictured left, an “international” version of The General, with Kevin Spacey donning a dodgy Irish accent to play the Cahill figure. the film was as funny and as celebrated as a train crash.
But I’d like to finish by paying tribute to Hollywood. We all know they don’t really care about authenticity, but when it comes to us Irish they’re particularly bad, employing Oirish accents and phrases we haven’t used in centuries. From The Quiet Man to Tom and Nicole’s terrible performances in Far and Away, I thank you Hollywood. For without your incompetence, this nation would never keep trying to make that one hit that overshadows your latest vacuous blockbuster.
Popularity: 1% [?]
Stumble it! / Bookmark:



March 14th, 2007 at 4:38 pm
You forgot I Went Down.
March 14th, 2007 at 9:26 pm
Interesting list. I’ve seen the top films cited except for Adam and Paul. Of Neil Jordan’s films, Butcher Boy is my favorite.
I thought Wind that Shakes the Barley could also be viewed as being about contemporary Iraq as well as Ireland.
As far as Hollywood’s version of Ireland, how do you rate Veronica Guerin?
The word is “canon”, but otherwise I’ll respectfully let you stick to your guns!
March 15th, 2007 at 4:46 am
Bif, I didn’t forget I Went Down. I just didn’t include. It’s a decent road movie but nothing spectacular.
Peter, thanks for the proof-read, my ‘n’ finger was a little trigger-happy.
As for Veronica Guerin, it has a great performance, but the film lacked imagination.
Interesting comment about Wind. I think it can only be an allegory in the broadest outlook. The details are too different to make direct comparisons.
March 15th, 2007 at 8:15 am
Really? I would have considered it a far tighter piece of cinema than either The Commitments or The Butcher Boy.
March 15th, 2007 at 9:05 am
As an Irishman, and a human being, I must say that I am deeply offended by your ugly words.
Or, in the words of the Black Donnely’s :
“The Irish have always been victims of a negative stereotype. I mean, people think we’re all drunks and brawlers — and sometimes that gets you so mad, all you want to is get drunk and punch somebody.”
March 15th, 2007 at 10:25 am
Bif, well, personally I would rate I Went Down slightly over The Commitments, but the latter had an impact abroad, whereas I Went Down got very minimal exposure outside of Ireland. The Commitments helped the film industry, I Went Down probably made its mony back at the very most.
Great quote, Quigs. But if you’ve ever walked through Dublin’s city centre on a Saturday night, the drunken stereotype seems mild.
March 15th, 2007 at 10:51 am
Fair enough, though in interviews Brendan Gleeson still talks about meeting people in Hollywood who compliment him on his performance in I Went Down. So on a, admittedly, much more low-key level it helped the film industry by adding a critically approved project to everyone involved’s cv. Did The Butcher Boy have a similar impact to The Commitments?
March 15th, 2007 at 11:02 am
My criteria for those top picks were films that either made a huge impact on the Irish industry or films that were just damn good. Butcher Boy did much better than I Went Down in worldwide B.O. but it was also a much better film, in my humble opinion.
I didn’t know that about Gleeson, which is interesting. I’d put I Went Down in my Top 10 list of Irish films, but I just don’t think it’s that good, nor that important in the industry, to give it a place on my lovely list. Though ironically I’ve written more on it in these comments than any of the films in the main article… damn you Bif!
March 15th, 2007 at 11:09 am
Yeah, I wasn’t sure how Butcher Boy did. I just didn’t like it.
You’ll be better off just agreeing with me in future.
April 1st, 2007 at 9:36 am
[...] Original post by eoin [...]
May 16th, 2007 at 2:59 pm
[...] achievements. Film too is a difficult medium to excel in with such little funds available, but that hasn’t stopped us from trying. The micro-budget film Once is an indie-rock musical set in Dublin, has made an impact on the [...]
March 13th, 2008 at 9:30 am
[...] taking place around the world, what better time to take a look at Irish cinema? Last year I posted an article about my favourite Irish films. But, if there’s one thing that can madden an Irish person, it’s [...]
March 17th, 2008 at 4:10 pm
Most films made in Ireland during the last few years were of a low budget and the majority of them never see the light of day or you will a long time to see them on DVD. A case in point “Pete’s Meteot” was shot around Dublin’s north inner city during 1998. the story is about two kids, a meteor and a miracle. with Mike Myers in the lead as a friend of the kids and he didn’t do a bad job,it wasn’t released in the cinema to my knowledge. The DVD was released at the end of last year, almost ten years after shooting finished. A long wait. A Hanna